How to Keep Cafe Customers Coming Back: Regulars, Loyalty Cards and Quiet Hours

Cafe regulars come back for the same coffee every time, a team that knows their order, and a reason to choose you over the cafe next door. Half of Australian cafe buyers get a barista coffee at least a few times a week, but only about one in six always goes to the same place. A simple buy nine, get one free card is what customers expect. One regular buying a $5.40 coffee three times a week is worth about $780 a year, before they ever order breakfast.

Nik Bavisetti
Nik Bavisetti· QwikPay Co-Founder
·Prices and rules checked ·8 min read
On this page
  1. 1Why regulars carry a cafe
  2. 2The same coffee every time
  3. 3Know names and orders
  4. 4Loyalty cards and rewards
  5. 5Fill quiet hours without discounting everything
  6. 6Turn weekday coffee into weekend breakfast
  7. 7Keep in touch when things change
  8. 8Frequently asked questions

Why regulars carry a cafe

A roaster-commissioned survey of Australian coffee buyers found 11% buy a barista coffee every day and 39% a few times a week. The same roaster's 2026 survey found just 17% always buy from the same cafe, while 57% usually go to one place but sometimes try others (Seven Miles). The weekday coffee regular is the base of a cafe: they fill the morning rush, bring colleagues, and come back on the weekend for breakfast.

Calculator

What is one regular worth?

Based on a small coffee three times a week. Change the numbers to match yours.

One regular, per year$778
One regular, over three years$2,333
20 regulars, per year$15,552

The same coffee every time

  • Write down your recipe (dose, yield and time) and milk temperature, and train every barista to it.
  • Dial in the grinder each morning and again when the weather or the beans change.
  • Keep your best baristas on the morning rush, when most regulars come in.
  • If a regular sends a coffee back, remake it without fuss. It costs you about $1.34 in ingredients.

Want all 6 guides in one, with a launch checklist? Get the full guide

Know names and orders

Starting a regular's usual as they walk in is the cheapest loyalty program there is. Write names and orders on a card behind the machine until the team knows them, and if your point of sale has customer profiles, add notes there.

Loyalty cards and rewards

In our survey of 45 independent cafes, 13 showed a coffee punch card on their ordering page, and the most common was buy nine or ten, get the next one free. That gives back about 10% to people who come often. Two Good Eggs in Sydney was the most generous we saw at buy eight, get the ninth free; a regional cafe asked for 19 coffees before the free one.

RewardHow it worksCost to you
Paper stamp cardA stamp per coffee and the tenth free. Cheap and familiar, but cards get lost and you cannot see who is coming back.The free coffee, about $1.34 in ingredients for a small flat white, plus printing
Point of sale or ordering app loyaltyStamps or points on the customer's phone or card, through your point of sale or online ordering. Some show you who your regulars are.The free coffee plus any add-on fee
QwikPay reward pointsCustomers earn points on every payment they make with the QwikPay app.No transaction fee, and you still receive 100% of each payment
A keep cup discountRegulars who bring a reusable cup get a small discount.The discount, less about 12c of cup and lid you do not use

Never trade stamps or free coffees for reviews

A free coffee or extra stamp for a Google review counts as an incentive under Google's rules, and reviews collected that way can be removed. The reviews guide explains what you can do instead.

Fill quiet hours without discounting everything

Most cafes are flat out from 7am to 9am and on weekend mornings, and quiet mid-afternoon. Rent and wages cost the same either way, so the quiet hours are where extra sales help most.

  • Run an offer only in the quiet window, such as double stamps after 2pm or a coffee and cake price from 2pm to close.
  • Add something for the afternoon crowd: school pick-up parents, gym-goers or office workers wanting a cold drink.
  • Take coffee-run and catering orders from nearby offices for the middle of the week.
  • Close earlier on your quietest day rather than paying staff to wait.
  • Once it launches, post quiet-hour offers in QwikClub, where customers who follow you see them in the QwikPay app.

Turn weekday coffee into weekend breakfast

A regular who knows your coffee is the easiest person to sell a weekend breakfast to. Mention the new seasonal dish when they pick up their coffee, put the weekend menu on the counter on Fridays, and remember them when they come in with family.

Keep in touch when things change

  • Post holiday hours and closures on Instagram, your Google profile and a sign on the door at least a week ahead.
  • Tell regulars in person about price changes before they happen.
  • Ask regulars what they would like on the menu. People come back to places they helped shape.
9:41
YCYour cafe

Text Message · SMS
Today 4:10 pm

Hi Rachel, a heads up from the cafe: we are closed from 24 December to 2 January. If your team wants a last coffee run or platters before the break, order by Monday 22nd and we will have it ready. Merry Christmas from all of us. Tom
Text Message
Telling a regular catering customer about holiday hours
Free by email

Get the full cafe guide

All 6 guides in one printable guide, with a launch checklist at the end. We'll email it to you now.

We'll also send four short emails over two weeks on pricing, first clients, reviews and keeping regulars. Unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.

Frequently asked questions

How often do cafe regulars come back?

A roaster-commissioned survey found 11% of Australian coffee buyers get a barista coffee every day and 39% a few times a week, with another 23% about once a week. Only 17% always buy from the same cafe, so regulars have to be earned.

What loyalty program should a cafe use?

A simple coffee card is what customers expect. In our survey of 45 independent cafes, the most common was buy nine or ten coffees, get the next one free. Reward coming back more often, not every visit.

How do I get more customers in quiet hours?

Run offers only in the quiet window, such as double stamps after 2pm, add something for the afternoon crowd, and take coffee-run and catering orders from nearby businesses. Avoid discounting your busy times.

General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules can differ by council, so check with yours before you open.

Cafe guides: all 6 parts

  1. 1How to Start a Cafe in Australia: Costs, Rules and First Steps
  2. 2Cafe Setup: Point of Sale, Payments, Ordering and Delivery Apps
  3. 3How to Get Your First Cafe Customers: Before and After Opening Day
  4. 4How Much to Charge in Your Cafe: Coffee and Breakfast Prices in Australia
  5. 5How to Get Google Reviews for Your Cafe
  6. 6How to Keep Cafe Customers Coming Back: Regulars, Loyalty Cards and Quiet Hours

Take payments with zero transaction fees

QwikPay works alongside your card reader. Customers pay from the app, earn reward points on every payment and, with QwikClub (coming soon), will be able to follow you and see your offers.